Before deciding how hard to paint a shadow edge, I look for what is casting it. In this reference, the softer shadow on the house and the broader shadows across the landscape give me different clues about their sources.
Compare the shadows in the reference
The shadow falling across the house is soft. I contrast it with an artificially hard version to show how a sharp boundary changes the effect. I relate the softer edge to trees standing farther from the wall.
Across the wooded hillside, I point out a very soft shadow that I identify as coming from a cloud. Nearby tree shadows have more distinct edges. Looking for the source helps me understand why those passages do not all need the same treatment.
Observe the edge before outlining it
It is easy to decide that a shape is a shadow and then give it a firm outline automatically. Instead, I want to study how clearly its boundary is visible in this particular scene.
I also mention the surface and angle involved. The practical lesson is to connect the shadow you paint with the object and light that produced it. In this example, comparing the sources helps me preserve the differences between a gentle transition and a more definite edge.
Continue with How to add transitional areas to your paintings and Direction of Light and Shadows.


