When it comes to painting and drawing, one fundamental debate among artists is the difference between using reference photos and painting plein air (directly from life). Both methods have their merits, but understanding the distinctions can significantly impact your artistic journey. 

Learning Directly from the Source

The core idea behind painting and drawing is to capture the essence of your subject as faithfully as possible. When you paint or draw from life, you're learning directly from the source. This direct engagement with your subject offers a level of intimacy and understanding that is often unparalleled. You're observing real-time changes in light, shadow, and color, which helps develop your ability to see and translate these elements onto your canvas.

The Filters of Photography

In contrast, using reference photos introduces several layers of separation between you and your subject. When you rely on a photo, you're viewing the subject through three filters:

1. The Camera Lens: This first filter can distort perspective, color, and depth. Even the best cameras can't capture the full dynamic range of light and color that the human eye can perceive.

2. The Camera Body: The second filter is the camera's internal processing. Cameras, especially digital ones, have sensors and algorithms that interpret and process the image, often resulting in a loss of subtle details.

3. The Monitor: Finally, when you view the photo on a monitor, you're dealing with another layer of potential distortion. Different screens have varying color calibrations and resolutions, which can further alter the appearance of the original scene.

The Plein Air Advantage

Painting plein air allows you to capture the true essence of a scene. You're immersed in the environment, feeling the breeze, hearing the sounds, and experiencing the changing light. This multisensory engagement enriches your perception and translates into more vibrant and dynamic artwork. You learn to observe and interpret subtle nuances that a photograph might miss, such as the play of light on a leaf or the way shadows move across the ground.

Embracing Both Methods

While plein-air painting offers a purer connection to the subject, reference photos still hold value, especially in practical terms. They can be incredibly useful for capturing fleeting moments or details that you can't spend hours observing in person. Many artists use a combination of both techniques: starting with plein air studies to capture the essence of a scene and then using photos to refine details back in the studio.

In conclusion, understanding the difference between painting from life and using reference photos is crucial for developing as an artist. Plein air painting offers an unfiltered, immersive experience that deepens your observational skills and enriches your artwork. While reference photos are convenient and valuable tools, being aware of their limitations and using them judiciously can help you maintain the authenticity and vitality of your artistic vision.

In the end, remember that the fountain is a direct observation, and once you get good at it, your studio work will improve by a hundredfold.

Learn tips like this and more with me below: